What the Gorsuch Confirmation Could Mean for Employers

by | 14 Apr, 2017

Sign up to The Compass for Monthly HR News, Tips & Trends!

We respect you and will never sell your information.

On April 7th, the Senate confirmed Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch, by a 54-45 vote, as the 113th Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court.On April 7th, the Senate confirmed Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch, by a 54-45 vote, as the 113th Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court. This process has been contentious, with much opposition from the Democratic side.  Gorsuch’s place on the Supreme Court, however, certainly helps Donald Trump in his attempts to reinstate a conservative leaning 5-4 court. All that being said, HR and benefits professionals in particular are wondering what exactly this confirmation will mean for future employment and labor cases.

Benefits experts say that the Gorsuch confirmation will likely benefit employers. He is expected to side with the other four conservative judges, and these judges have often taken a pro-business approach. Many are looking to Gorsuch’s track record and previously expressed opinions to get an idea of what decisions he may be making in the future.

In the past, Gorsuch has rejected expansive views of employment laws and administrative agencies’ authority, meaning he does not tend to defer to the agencies’ view of regulations or interpretations of federal laws. Gorsuch’s predecessor, Justice Scalia, tended to support the deferential approach, so his replacement by Gorsuch could to more employer-friendly results, as the agencies often make interpretations that favor employees.

Furthermore, some of his past decisions show that he is willing to uphold NLRB decisions that are consistent with its precedents and not arbitrary. In 2016, however, Gorsuch dissented a Tenth Circuit decision to uphold a NLRB decision that provided a method of calculating backpay in instances where unionized employees’ hours were wrongly cut. Though this decision to uphold favored employees, Gorsuch opposed it, claiming that it was not consistent with methods used for calculating backpay in other contexts.

In Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. v. Sebelius, which ruled that closely-held corporations had the right to evade the Affordable Care Act’s contraceptive mandate on religious grounds, Gorsuch wrote a concurrence. When the case was appealed to the Supreme Court, that concurrence influenced Justice Alito’s majority opinion to maintain that forcing companies to provide coverage for contraception is in violation of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

In conclusion, Gorsuch’s track record suggests that he may lean towards decisions that are more employer-friendly. He is expected to side with the other 4 conservative judges on the Supreme Court, who tend to take a pro-business approach. While this could signify that Gorsuch’s place on the Supreme Court will be good for employers, it is important to note that many employment related issues are very complex, and it is very difficult to know for certain how specific judges will rule in various cases.

Tom DiSilva
Tom DiSilva has been providing professional human resource services for over 30 years. As the CEO of Navigate PEO, he actively partners with organizations of all sizes in the Greater New England area and across the country to help their businesses grow. He has expertise in HR and Labor Management, offering guidance and support for key areas of business such as negotiations, operations management, employee coaching, and employee benefits design. He is an active member of The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), The National Association of Professional Employer Organizations (NAPEO), Professional Association of Co-Employers (PACE), and The American Payroll Association (APA). He is deeply committed to giving back to the community both personally and through Navigate Cares, which provides support for several nonprofit organizations such as the USO, The Boys & Girls Club, and the 3Point Foundation.

Continue reading helpful HR articles from Tom.

Navigating A Post-Pandemic Return To Work

As we see restrictions starting to lift, we’re seeing companies start to send their employees back to work in the office as long as it’s safe to do so and a proper risk management plan is in place.

Providing Help for Caregivers Within the Workplace

An estimated 1 in 6 working Americans today support their parents or another member of the elderly community. Read how to invest in employees that are in an unpaid caregiving function at home that you might not even be aware of.

Disclaimer: this article does not represent expert advice and is provided for informational purposes. Please get in touch if you would like expert HR advice.